On primate behavior and tracing back the origins of morality

Personally, I have my own beef with sociobiology a.k.a. evolutionary psychology. I have yet to see it venture from a story telling, subjective science. But my issues don’t prevent me from acknowledging and respecting progressive work done in this subfield of behavioral studies and primatology.

Primate MoralityI don’t know where Nick Wade truly stands about sociobiology, but I can tell he generally shares my sentiments on appreciating this issue, because he has eloquently summarized the work of Frans de Waal in his new article in the New York Times. I trust that you can tell what the topic and the scope of article is by reading the title, “Scientist Finds the Beginnings of Morality in Primate Behavior.”

At its core, this article is useful because it outlines the four basic behaviors for sociality, empathy, the ability to learn and follow social rules, reciprocity and peacemaking. If you think about it, our social structure is founded on it, and based off of years of Frans’ observations of chimps, macaques, and rhesus monkeys these traits exist to some degree in non-human primates.

Dr. de Waal makes the tangent that human morality has spawned off of primate sociality,

“but with two extra levels of sophistication. People enforce their society’s moral codes much more rigorously with rewards, punishments and reputation building. They also apply a degree of judgment and reason, for which there are no parallels in animals. “

The article goes on with a discussion on how Frans has stood up to criticism, competing and contrasting theories on the origins of human morality. I also noticed Nick opens talk about the origins and concept of religion, something I talked about here. But aside from the intricate subtopics, at the very minimum this article also provides us with some insight on why some of us study primate behavior…. even if it is story telling.

😉

I’m curious to open this thread up to a discussion of how and where we think we developed our sense of morality? Is morality a behavioral trait inherited from our evolutionary relatives? Or is our morality a bi-product of our human only cultures? What do you think? Is there a grey area between these two? Can we ever truly find out where morality originated?

10 thoughts on “On primate behavior and tracing back the origins of morality

  1. My personal off-the-cuff opinion is that each person’s sense of morality and ethics is partly hard-wired genetically and partly a matter of socialization. I have no way of saying how the ratios work out. Previously, I believed that socialization was the bigger factor, but I’ve been convinced enough by some of Steven Pinker’s arguments to begin to seriously think that the genetic basis might have a bigger role.

    What I’m absolutely not convinced by is the C.S. Lewis-style arguments that claim each person’s moral compass has been placed there supernaturally by God.
    Very interesting topic!
    Dave

  2. Perhaps evolutional morality is a type of Darwinian cultural filter of genes.

    The body of work which E.O. Wilson (and likely others) has pointed to as meriting increasing focus — the connection between the science of genetics and sociobiology or human behavior — may discover that genes are less causative than behavior … the genes merely being the scorekeepers for behaviors.

  3. Consumers should beware of fake ugg boots. The dictionary definition of an “ugg boot” is “a sheepskin boot with the wool on the inside”. An ugg boot must be made of real sheepskin. Due to the high cost of genuine sheepskin, one of the first warning bells will be a so called “ugg boot” advertised at a very cheap price. Make sure you have the genuine article before purchasing. Genuine sheepskin will outlast many synthetic products. Sheepskin is a natural product which breathes, absorbs moisture and provides a warmth and comfort superior to any synthetics. (Most synthetics become very smelly with wear). Real sheepskin has the wool tanned into the leather. Fake sheepskin can easily be recognised – if you part the fibres lining the boot with your fingers and there is a woven or knitted backing under the fibres it is NOT real sheepskin.

    Care when buying online
    Before buying online it’s a good idea to carefully read through the website. Check that there is a physical address for the company, a landline phone number (not a cell phone) and a legitimate email address you can contact. Most genuine businesses are more than happy to make this information available. So, before you hand over your credit card details do your homework. For peace of mind when buying online we recommend you buy from one of our members.

    http://pentecostalismonline.com/activity/p/31967/%5Dhttp://pentecostalismonline.com/activity/p/31967/
    http://hamzetwasel.com/activity/p/30229/%5Dhttp://hamzetwasel.com/activity/p/30229/
    http://updown.ee/jibb/activity/p/3644/%5Dhttp://updown.ee/jibb/activity/p/3644/
    http://biltec.org/activity/p/59399/%5Dhttp://biltec.org/activity/p/59399/
    http://nashvilleceoroundtable.com/activity/p/38466/%5Dhttp://nashvilleceoroundtable.com/activity/p/38466/

  4. A lot of people send their own elderly folks to nursing homes especially if they have not an adequate amount of living space at-home to accommodate elderly members of the family. But, nursing homes are really expensive plus some of them don’t possess the greatest amenities. If you do not want to send your own elderly folks towards a nursing home but you don’t have sufficient space in your own home just for them, why not give consideration to home extension and build a granny flat in your residence?

    Click Here For More Info

  5. Avec six paires d’articles chaussants achetes en moyenne chaque annee par habitant, la France reste le premier pays europeen consommateur de chaussures. Mais crise oblige, le secteur souffre lui aussi. Et le debut d’annee a ete particulierement difficile, avec un premier semestre en recul de 3%. Mais ?on corrige un peu sur le second semestreavec une ?saison d’automne qui a demarre correctement?, explique le president de la Federation francaise de la chaussure (FFC), Jean-Pierre Renaudin. La prime de rentree a permis au marche de la chaussure enfant ?de retrouver un petit peu de souffle. Si bien que l’annee 2012 ?devrait afficher une tres legere regression, autour de moins 1%, moins 2%?, estime Dorval Ligonniere, responsable etudes et marketing a la FFC. L’industrie francaise de la chaussure est aussi soutenue par les exportations qui continuent de progresser, avec une hausse de 15% en valeur sur les six premiers mois 2012. Le made in France fait recette ?Le made in France est tres apprecie sur les grands marches, aux etats-Unis, en Asie, en Russie, au Moyen-Orient (…) ce qui permet aux industriels de bien resister, meme si le marche francais est un petit peu plus difficile?, a releve le responsable marketing. En 2011, la France a exporte 80millions de paires de chaussures, pour un montant de 1,7 milliard d’euros, avec l’Europe comme principaux pays destinataires (Italie, Espagne, Allemagne, Belgique, Royaume-Uni). Mais la meme annee, quelque 481 millions de paires ont ete importees pour 4,7 milliards d’euros, venant principalement de Air Jordan, d’pas cher basket des chaussures, du Vietnam, du jordan talon et d’Indonesie.

Comments are closed.

A WordPress.com Website.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: